First Observation of an Attractive Interaction between a Proton and a Cascade Baryon

This Letter presents the first experimental observation of the attractive strong interaction between a proton and a multistrange baryon (hyperon) Ξ−. The result is extracted from two-particle correlations of combined p-Ξ− ⊕ p̄-Ξ̄þ pairs measured in p-Pb collisions at ffiffiffiffiffiffiffi sNN p 1⁄4 5.02 TeV at the LHC with ALICE. The measured correlation function is compared with the prediction obtained assuming only an attractive Coulomb interaction and a standard deviation in the range [3.6, 5.3] is found. Since the measured p-Ξ− ⊕ p̄-Ξ̄þ correlation is significantly enhanced with respect to the Coulomb prediction, the presence of an additional, strong, attractive interaction is evident. The data are compatible with recent lattice calculations by the HAL-QCD Collaboration, with a standard deviation in the range [1.8, 3.7]. The lattice potential predicts a shallow repulsive Ξ− interaction within pure neutron matter and this implies stiffer equations of state for neutron-rich matter including hyperons. Implications of the strong interaction for the modeling of neutron stars are discussed.

Hyperons are baryons containing at least one strange quark (e.g., Λ ¼ uds, Σ 0 ¼ uds, Ξ − ¼ ssd) and hyperonnucleon interactions are the object of intensive studies for two main purposes.The first one is to achieve a level of precision in the strangeness sector of low-energy quantum chromodynamics (QCD) comparable to the one reached in the determination of the scattering parameters of nucleonnucleon interactions.The second purpose is to study the impact of the strong interaction between baryons with strangeness on the description of dense objects within astrophysics [1][2][3][4].
Effective field theory provides a systematic expansion scheme to compute hyperon-nucleon and hyperon-hyperon interactions [4,5] but currently the experimental constraints are rather scarce.
Hyperon-nucleon (pΛ, pΩ) and hyperon-hyperon (ΛΛ) interactions were already investigated by means of twoparticle correlations in the momentum space measured in heavy-ion collisions by the STAR collaboration [14][15][16].However, these analyses are hampered by large statistical uncertainties or by contamination by nongenuine contributions to the correlation function [17], and hence new experimental approaches are called for.
Recently it has been shown that hyperon-nucleon, hyperon-hyperon [18,19], and kaon-nucleon [20] interactions can be more precisely measured in proton-proton (pp) and proton-lead (p-Pb) collisions at the LHC.Indeed, small colliding systems at LHC energies lead to particleemitting sources with sizes of about 1 fm, allowing a precise test of the short-range strong interaction.With an emitting source size similar to that of pp collisions [21], the larger number of pairs available in the data set recorded from p-Pb collisions at ffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ffi s NN p ¼ 5.02 TeV by ALICE allows these studies to be extended to the p-Ξ − correlation.The newly developed tool CATS (correlation analysis tool using the Schrödinger equation) [22] allows us to compute predictions for the p-Ξ − correlation considering either only the known Coulomb interaction or including additionally a strong potential.The direct comparison of the measured and predicted correlation functions provides an unprecedented tool to test the strong p-Ξ interaction.
In this Letter, we present the first evidence of a strong attractive interaction in the p-Ξ − channel.We also compare the experimental correlation to the prediction obtained employing lattice calculations from the HAL-QCD Collaboration [23,24] for the p-Ξ − interaction.This, but also any other p-Ξ − potential, can be then used to evaluate the single-particle potential of the Ξ − within pure neutron matter [25].The possible appearance of Ξ − within dense neutron matter depends on this single-particle potential [26].An attractive single-particle potential for the Ξ − within pure neutron matter would favor the appearance of Ξ − at already moderate densities [27], softening the equation of state (EOS), while a repulsive single-particle potential [3] would shift the Ξ − production to larger densities [4] and stiffen the EOS.
These studies are relevant for the modeling of neutron stars since, due to the large densities achieved in the center of these objects, neutrons might transform into hyperons to minimize the system energy [28].So far primarily Λ hyperons are included in theoretical calculations because the Λ-nucleon interaction is better known than the Ξ-nucleon and Σ-nucleon interactions, but all the three hyperon-species and their interactions with nucleons should be considered to achieve a realistic equation of state.
It is clear that the precise measurement of the p-Ξ − strong interaction will allow for a sound determination of the corresponding single-particle potential and consequently for more realistic EOSs of neutron stars with hyperon content.
This Letter presents p-p ⊕ p-p and p-Ξ − ⊕ p-Ξþ correlations measured in p-Pb collisions at ffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ffi s NN p ¼ 5.02 TeV employing the data set collected by ALICE [29,30] in 2016 during the LHC Run 2. As the correlation functions of baryon-baryon pairs exhibit identical behavior compared to their respective anti-baryon-anti-baryon pairs [31,32], the corresponding samples are combined.Therefore, in the following p-p denotes the combination of p-p ⊕ p-p, and accordingly for p-Ξ − .Collision events are triggered by the coincidence in the V0 scintillator arrays [33], which is also used to reject background events stemming from interactions of the beam particles with the beam-pipe materials or beam gas.Pile-up events with more than one p-Pb collision per bunch crossing are rejected by evaluating the presence of multiple event vertices.To assure a uniform detector coverage, the distance along the beam axis between the reconstructed primary vertex and the nominal interaction point is required to be smaller than 10 cm.After these selection criteria are applied, about 600 × 10 6 minimum-bias events are available for the analysis.
The main detectors used in the analysis are the inner tracking system (ITS) [29] and the time projection chamber (TPC) [34], covering the full azimuthal angle and the pseudorapidity range of jηj < 0.9.These detectors are located within a solenoid that creates a magnetic field of B ¼ 0.5 T directed along the beam axis.The measurement of the specific ionization energy loss, dE=dx, in the TPC gas, and the time information delivered by the time of flight (TOF) [35] detector are used for particle identification (PID).Particles originating from weak decays are differentiated from primary [36] particles originating at the collision point since their associated tracks do not point to the primary vertex [30].
The proton candidates are identified following the same criteria listed in [18].The TPC and TOF PID capabilities are used to select protons by the deviation of the PID signal from its expectation value normalized to units of standard deviations n σ;proton of the detector resolution (σ TPC , σ TOF ).DPMJET [37] Monte Carlo events processed such as to emulate the ALICE detector acceptance and reconstruction algorithm [29] are used to estimate the purity and composition of the selected samples.Both proton and antiproton samples are found to have a purity of 97%, and to consist of 86% primary particles.
The Ξ − baryons are reconstructed [38] using the decay channel Ξ − → Λπ − [39].The Λ is identified by its decay channel Λ → pπ − [39].The charged particles employed in the Ξ − reconstruction are selected via PID with jn σ;TPC;i j < 4 (i ¼ π, p), and they are required to have a hit in one of the ITS layers or a matched TOF signal in order to use timing information to remove the contribution of particles stemming from out-of-bunch pileup.The Λ candidates are selected by applying the following topological criteria: (i) a minimum distance for the Λ daughter tracks to the primary vertex of 0.05 cm, (ii) a maximum distance between the two daughter tracks of 1.5 cm, (iii) the radial distance of the Λ decay vertex to the detector center in radial coordinates, r xy , in the range 1.4 to 200 cm, and (iv) the cosine of the pointing angle (CPA) between the Λ momentum and the vector connecting the primary and decay vertices is required to be CPA > 0.97.
The Λ invariant mass is calculated using the pion and proton hypothesis for the daughters and is described by a double Gaussian, accounting for the signal and the mass resolution, and a second-order polynomial for the combinatorial background.The resulting average mass resolution is 2.0 MeV=c 2 independent of transverse momentum (p T ) of the selected candidates.A total of 18.0 × 10 6 (17.6 × 10 6 ) Λ ( Λ) candidates are selected within AE3σ around the nominal mass, with a signal (S) to background (B) ratio S=B of 5.1 (5.4) corresponding to a purity of 83.5% (84.3%).
A π − candidate track is combined with the selected Λ candidate to form a Ξ − and evaluate its decay vertex.The following topological selection criteria are applied: (i) a minimum distance for the π − to the primary vertex of 0.05 cm, (ii) a maximum distance between the track of the π − and the Λ of 1.5 cm, (iii) a r xy of the Ξ − decay vertex between 0.8 and 200 cm, and (iv) a minimum Ξ − CPA of 0.98.The Ξ − mass resolution increases from 2.1 MeV=c 2 at low p T to 2.7 MeV=c 2 at larger p T , with a p T averaged value of 2.3 MeV=c 2 .Applying a AE2σ selection of the average value around the nominal Ξ − mass, a S=B ratio of 7.3 (7.9), resulting in purities of 87.9% (88.6%), is estimated for Ξ − ( Ξþ ).A total of 8 × 10 5 Ξ candidates of each charge are selected.The fraction of primary particles is calculated considering measured production rates of Ω [40] and Ξ 0 ð1530Þ [41], and assuming for the Ξ − ð1530Þ a similar production rate as for the Ξ 0 ð1530Þ.The total sample is hence estimated to consist of 66.1% primary particles.
PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS 123, 112002 (2019) 112002- 2Experimentally, the correlation function is computed as , Aðk Ã Þ represents the same event k Ã distribution, and Bðk Ã Þ is a corresponding reference sample of uncorrelated pairs obtained by pairing particles from different events [18].The normalization constant N between the two distributions is obtained in the region k Ã ∈ ½240; 340 MeV=c, where final state interaction effects are absent and the correlation function is flat.The theoretical correlation function Letter is computed with CATS [22], where r is the relative distance between the two particles, SðrÞ is the source function, and ψ k Ã ðrÞ is the twoparticle wave function.A spherically symmetric emitting source with a Gaussian density profile parametrized by a radius parameter r 0 is assumed and Coulomb and strong potentials are considered to evaluate the relative wave functions for p-p and p-Ξ − pairs.
The measured correlation functions for p-p and p-Ξ − are shown in Fig. 1.The inset in the left panel shows an enlargement of the p-p correlation function around k Ã ¼ 100 MeV=c, where the effect of the repulsive interaction can be seen.A total number of 574 × 10 3 (412 × 10 3 ) p-p ( p-p) and 3.3 × 10 3 (2.6 × 10 3 ) p-Ξ − ( p-Ξþ ) pairs contribute to Aðk Ã Þ in the region k Ã < 200 MeV=c.The systematic uncertainties for the p-p and p-Ξ − correlations are obtained by varying all single-particle selection criteria for protons and Ξ candidates with respect to their default values such as to obtain a maximum variation of the single particle yields of AE15%.The resulting uncertainties on the correlation functions are symmetrized and added in quadrature.
In order not to be dominated by statistical fluctuations, the systematic uncertainties are evaluated in intervals of 40 MeV=c width in k Ã for p-p and 200 MeV=c for p-Ξ − , and fitted by a second order polynomial which serves to interpolate the final point-by-point correlated uncertainties in narrower intervals.The total systematic uncertainty reaches a maximum value of 5% for p-p and 3.2% for p-Ξ − at the lowest measured k Ã value.
The experimental data are fitted with the model correlation function obtained from CATS, C model ðk Ã Þ. Together with the genuine correlation function due to the twoparticle interaction, residual correlations are also considered.In the experiment the latter are introduced by contamination of the selected samples due to particle misidentification and feed-down from weak decays of other particles.These are taken into account according to where C genuine ðk Ã Þ is the genuine correlation function for the pairs of interest, i and j denote all possible impurity and feed-down contributions, and C ij ðk Ã Þ represent the corresponding correlation functions.The parameters λ ij are the relative weights of these contributions calculated from purity and feed-down fractions [18] and are summarized in Table I.Here X denotes misidentified particles and X Y particles originating from the decay of Y.Both the p-p and p-Ξ − correlation functions are dominated by the genuine correlation of interest.The main contribution contaminating the p-p correlation function are protons from Λ or Σ þ weak decays.The genuine p-Ξ − signal is diluted with contributions from secondary protons as mentioned above, misidentified Ξs, or from decays of the Ξð1530Þ resonance.
For the feed-down contributions, the shape of the  1).Their widths correspond to one standard deviation of the systematic error of the fit.The HAL-QCD curve uses potentials obtained from Ref. [42].The dashed line in the right panel shows the contribution from misidentified p-Ξ− pairs from the sidebands scaled by its λ parameter.See text for details.
correlations is obtained by transforming the initial theoretical correlation function [43] of the mother particles via the corresponding decay matrices [44].For most combinations this results in a flat C ij ðk Ã Þ ∼ 1.For contributions with misidentified particles a flat correlation is assumed except for the case of p-Ξ− , where experimental data from the sidebands of the invariant mass selection are used.This contribution is also shown in Fig. 1 after scaling according to The genuine p-p correlation function is computed by using the Coulomb and the strong Argonne v 18 [45] potentials, considering s and p waves.The radius r 0 of the emitting source is a free parameter determined by a fit to the experimental p-p correlation function, conducted in k Ã ∈ ½0; 375 MeV=c.A normalization parameter a is included for the final fit function to the data C tot ðk Ã Þ in the form C tot ðk Ã Þ ¼ aC model ðk Ã Þ, and it is also determined by the fit, driven by the flat region extending from 200 MeV=c.The theoretical correlation is smeared to account for the finite momentum resolution.
Although Fig. 1 shows that no minijet background is visible for baryon-baryon correlations [18,46], possible deformations of the correlation function due to energy and momentum conservation were considered by extending the fit procedure.A systematic variation of the fit is carried out by adding a baseline The parameters a and b are estimated from the fit to the p-p data.Additional systematic uncertainties of the fit and of the radius r 0 are evaluated by varying (i) the range of the fit region up to 350 or 400 MeV=c, and (ii) the λ parameters by modifying the secondary contributions by AE20% while keeping the sum of the primary and secondary fractions constant.The widths of the filled bands in Fig. 1 correspond to one standard deviation of the total systematic error of the fit.
The resulting radius r 0 ¼1.427AE0.007ðstatÞþ0.001 −0.014 ðsystÞfm obtained by a fit with a χ 2 =ndf ¼ 1.42 is then used in the computation of the p-Ξ − correlation function, following the premise of a common Gaussian source.Differences in the multiplicity dependence of the radius for p-p and p-Ξ − pairs have been investigated and found to be negligible.For the p-Ξ − interaction, two scenarios were tested: one considering only the Coulomb interaction and a second one with an additional strong potential computed on the lattice and provided by the HAL-QCD Collaboration [42].
Figure 2 shows the Ξ-nucleon strong interaction potential as a function of the pair separation distance r for the different combinations of isospin (I ¼ 0, 1) and spin (S ¼ 0, 1).The widths of the potentials correspond to the uncertainties of the lattice calculations.The inset shows the correlation functions computed with the average values of each component of the potential and for a source radius equal to 1.4 fm.The different correlation functions obtained for the four I, S channels show the sensitivity to p-Ξ − distances lower than 1.5 fm.Nevertheless, a precise test of the potential for small distances will be possible only by improving the statistical uncertainties of the measurement by a factor of 10, as expected during the LHC Run 3.
The genuine total p-Ξ − correlation is obtained by computing the correlation function including the Coulomb and strong interaction for the four different states with CATS and then summing up the correlation functions with their specific statistical weights, The computation of the p-Ξ − correlations is carried out by first fitting the normalization parameter a in the range  k Ã ∈ ½250; 600 MeV=c, where the correlation function is flat.Then, using the resulting C tot ðk Ã Þ, the correlation function is compared with experimental data.
Systematic uncertainties of the predicted p-Ξ − correlation function from Coulomb and Coulomb þ strong interaction are evaluated by varying (i) the range where the normalization parameter a is estimated to k Ã ∈ ½300; 550 and k Ã ∈ ½350; 700 MeV=c, (ii) the fit procedure by including the baseline C nonfemto ðk Ã Þ ¼ ða þ bk Ã Þ, (iii) the λ parameters by modifying the secondary contributions by AE20% while keeping primary and secondary fractions constant, and (iv) the radius r 0 by decreasing it by 20% to account for possible variation of the p-Ξ − source with respect to the p-p source due to the larger contribution of strong Δ decays to the latter.The theoretical correlation is smeared to account for the finite momentum resolution and its width in Fig. 1 corresponds to one standard deviation of the total systematic uncertainty in the model evaluation.
The comparison of the experimental p-Ξ − data with the predicted correlation functions including only the Coulomb potential and the Coulomb þ strong potential in Fig. 1 shows that the latter is favored.The fact that the experimental p-Ξ − correlation function shows a stronger enhancement than the Coulomb-only assumption is able to produce means that the total interaction is more attractive than the assumption of a Coulomb-only interaction.The exclusion of this scenario is quantified by computing the p value of the data-model comparison considering statistical and systematic errors.To account for the systematic errors of the experimental data, the yield in each k Ã bin is smeared according to a Gaussian distribution with a width equal to the systematic error of each bin and all obtained permutations are compared to the Coulomb-only and Coulomb þ strong correlation functions.The obtained p values are converted into n σ values.The Coulomb-only correlation function is compared with the data in k Ã ∈ ½0; 140 MeV=c and the obtained n σ distributions present a standard deviation from 3.6 to 5.3.For the Coulomb þ strong interaction, the n σ values range from 1.8 to 3.7.The observation of a significant deviation between measured correlation function and the prediction using only the Coulomb interaction provides strong evidence for an attractive strong potential in the p-Ξ system.
In order to evaluate the consequences of this new observation for the EOS of neutron stars, the Ξ − singleparticle potential in pure neutron matter (PNM) at saturation density from HAL-QCD can be considered.This results in a slight repulsion for Ξ − in PNM of around 6 MeV [25].Since current models [47] include a much wider range ∈ ½−40; 40 MeV=c for such Ξ − single partice potential, the validated lattice predictions impose a much more stringent constraint with consequences for the EOS containing hyperons.The slight repulsion that the Ξ − single-particle potential acquires in PNM translates into larger densities for the appearance of Ξ − within neutron-rich matter and into a stiffer EOS.The data to be collected at the LHC in the future will provide the opportunity to study also baryon-antibaryon combinations such as antiproton-Ξ − correlations.
In summary, this Letter presents the first measurement of the p-Ξ − correlation function in p-Pb collisions at ffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ffi s NN p ¼ 5.02 TeV.A fit of the p-p correlation function with a model including a quantitative treatment of residual correlations yields a radius of r 0 ¼ 1.427 AE 0.007ðstatÞ þ0.001 −0.014 ðsystÞ fm for the emitting source of the particles.The p-Ξ − correlation is compared with Coulomb and Coulomb þ strong interaction assumptions and a deviation between 3.6 and 5.3 n σ to the Coulomb-only correlation is measured.This means that an attractive p-Ξ − strong interaction is observed.The lattice potential provided by the HAL-QCD Collaboration for the p-Ξ − interaction is found to be consistent with our measurements with n σ values from 1.8 to 3.7.This measurement constrains models of neutron stars containing hyperons to stiffer EOS.Additional data will allow different models [48] to be more precisely tested in order to conclude on the presence of Ξ − hyperons within neutron stars.
The ALICE Collaboration would like to thank all its engineers and technicians for their invaluable contributions to the construction of the experiment and the CERN accelerator teams for the outstanding performance of the LHC complex.The ALICE Collaboration gratefully acknowledges the resources and support provided by all Grid centres and the Worldwide LHC Computing Grid (WLCG) collaboration.The ALICE Collaboration acknowledges the following funding agencies for their support in building and running the ALICE detector: A. I.

FIG. 1 .
FIG. 1.The (a) p-p and (b) p-Ξ − correlation functions shown as a function of k Ã .Statistical (bars) and systematic uncertainties (boxes) are shown separately.The filled bands denote the results from the fit with Eq. (1).Their widths correspond to one standard deviation of the systematic error of the fit.The HAL-QCD curve uses potentials obtained from Ref.[42].The dashed line in the right panel shows the contribution from misidentified p-Ξ− pairs from the sidebands scaled by its λ parameter.See text for details.

1 FIG. 2 .
FIG.2.Predictions for the Ξ-nucleon potential from the HAL-QCD Collaboration[42] for the different spin (S) and isospin (I) states.The error bands refer to different Euclidean times considered in the calculation.The inset shows the correlation function computed with the central value of the potential for each of the different states and a source radius of 1.4 fm.

TABLE I .
Weight of the individual components of the p-p and p-Ξ − correlation function.Entries in the form X Y denote particles originating from the decay of Y, whereas X denotes misidentified particles.Nonflat contributions are listed individually.