Fractionalization, topological order, and cuprate superconductivity

This paper is concerned with the idea that the electron is fractionalized in the cuprate high-$T_c$ materials. We show how the notion of topological order may be used to develop a precise theoretical characterization of a fractionalized phase in spatial dimension higher than 1. Apart from the fractional particles into which the electron breaks apart, there are nontrivial gapped topological excitations—dubbed “visons.” A cylindrical sample that is fractionalized exhibits two disconnected topological sectors depending on whether a vison is trapped in the “hole” or not. Indeed, “vison expulsion” is to fractionalization what the Meissner effect (“flux expulsion”) is to superconductivity. This understanding enables us to address a number of conceptual issues that need to be confronted by any theory of the cuprates based on fractionalization ideas. We argue that whether or not the electron fractionalizes in the cuprates is a sharp and well-posed question with a definite answer. We elaborate on our recent proposal for an experiment to unambiguously settle this issue.